The currency of the modern age

September 2017 · Data & loyalty in retail · From the Ja Trgovac archive

First published in Croatian in Ja Trgovac, the Croatian retail trade magazine, September 2017 issue (pp. 50–51), as “Valuta modernog doba”. Republished here in English translation without changes. At the time, Goran was CTO of PayOut. Figures, products and regulation are described as they stood in September 2017.

Advanced technology has enabled merchants to offer much more to end customers, but also to get much more in return, through the currency of the modern age: data.

As an old English saying goes, “There is no such thing as a free lunch”. Loosely translated, it means that nobody gives something without expecting something in return, however things may seem at first. One could perhaps debate honorable exceptions, but as a rule today’s world, unfortunately, works on this principle. The same, of course, applies in commerce. And today more than ever. In the era before online retail, mobile apps and other technological aids, merchants used that “free lunch”, namely discounts, promotions and special offers, to bring you into their store, get you to buy a few more products along with the discounted one, and thereby, without realizing it, pay for what you “got”. Today the whole story, though essentially the same, is on a far higher level. Advanced technology has enabled merchants to offer much more to end customers, but also to get much more in return, through the currency of the modern age: data.

We all leave a trace

Data is the fuel of the modern business world, and perhaps nowhere is this as pronounced as in the world of commerce. Optimizing the business down to the micro level, with precise knowledge of every individual customer’s habits, means two things: savings and increased revenue. The holy grail of business. It is therefore no wonder that investment in technology for collecting and processing data is enormous and ranks at the very top of technology investment in the retail industry. But a big role in all of this is also played by the fact that today’s customer is likewise willing to give this data in order to get an offer tailored to them. Time and money are things few people can say they have in abundance, so customers prefer any offer that saves both. According to the latest 2017 survey by the consulting and audit firm PricewaterhouseCoopers, carried out on a sample of more than 20,000 respondents worldwide, almost 60% of them identified the possibility of a personalized offer as one of the most important areas in which the industry can improve. This desire is no accident. The lives of modern people are dominated by social networks, and that is an indisputable fact. What we do, what we like, who we spend time with and where: all of this is information that social networks like Facebook diligently collect and process in order to show us, on our smartphone screens, exactly those things and events that are relevant to us. And they know they are relevant to us because we told them so. With our data. Facebook and Google owe their size and value precisely to this data, that is, to the enormous earnings from advertisers (read: merchants), who pay astronomical sums knowing that there is a high probability that, precisely because of this data, their offer will find its way to a future customer who needs that very product, finds it suitable, or for whom it simply fits their lifestyle. This is capital that no serious merchant wants to give up, and from year to year investment in this segment grows while the boundaries of privacy shrink. Google recently went a step further and announced plans for the US market to track payment card purchases in the physical world and compare that data with data from the online world, thus precisely defining models of consumer behavior when making purchase decisions, as well as the effectiveness of advertising on mobile and web platforms. It seems frightening, but unfortunately the digital trace of today’s average consumer is scattered all over the internet, and Google is very effective at collecting and processing these traces.

Lack of a targeted approach

Of course, the question always arises: how far have we in Croatia come in this regard? Does our retail industry follow trends and invest in technology (at least in the context of end contact with customers)? We can say that the domestic digital retail space follows global trends fairly well. More and more domestic merchants (or foreign merchants present on our soil) use social networks quite intensively to advertise their products and communicate with customers, using sophisticated methodology of targeted, i.e. contextual, advertising. Despite this, they still lag behind in using data to address potential customers in a targeted way. The natural tool for this kind of application is, of course, loyalty programs, which use data precisely to give customers what they want.

Konzum (until recently the most powerful retail chain in Croatia), before it was hit by the crisis, had announced, through by far the largest domestic coalition loyalty program, MultiPlusCard, that it would take the program to a new level with more effective use of purchase data in order to give customers rewards and discounts tailored to their shopping habits. That would certainly have been welcome news in our market and would surely have met with a positive reaction from customers. When, and whether, these announcements will come true remains to be seen. Other retail chains still use data in a broader, macro picture, mostly adjusting their assortment and business to some kind of demographic analytics, and less through a personally tailored and targeted approach to customers. That is precisely why loyalty programs are more or less similar and offer generic rewards and discounts without taking into account the individual needs and preferences of customers. However, since we are part of the EU, some changes will simply reach us through sheer inertia, if in no other way. In fact, one of them is happening as early as next year through EU legislation.

A direct link with customers

One of the main changes in the world of banking, and the top topic of most financial technology conferences in recent years, is the now famous PSD2, the Payment Service Directive 2. This is an EU regulation which, through implementation in national legislation, becomes mandatory for all member states and the participants in their payment systems. Although at first glance it looks like something that concerns only the banking sector, the implementation of this regulation will have a significant impact on all participants in the chain, and especially on merchants. Although the topic itself is not that new, the fact that it comes into force in a few months (January 2018) makes it topical in the world of finance and beyond. What is it about? The regulation itself is quite extensive and defines a series of “rules of the game” in the financial world, but the main subject of countless articles, panels and discussions on the topic is the binding rule known as “XS2A”, “access to account”. XS2A, or access to account, is the obligation of all banks in the EU to give institutions that meet certain conditions access, free of charge, to information on their customers’ accounts and, most importantly for merchants, to enable those same institutions to initiate payments directly and transfer funds from one account to another.

In practice, this means that under this regulation merchants themselves can register as payment service providers in their own name and make payments without any intermediaries and, most importantly, without fees. When an item is bought in a web shop, the merchant will initiate a transfer of funds from the customer’s account to its own account, with no intermediary, no bank and no fee. E-commerce giants such as Amazon are already waiting, ready to register when PSD2 comes into force and thus give themselves a direct payment link with customers in the EU. Since the registration conditions have been set quite leniently, we have no doubt that many large regional e-commerce players will decide to make the same move. And the smaller ones, which will not have the resources, knowledge and capital for independent registration, will be able to achieve the same by using a kind of “principal” arrangement with large providers, and thus in many cases bypass the banks that carry online payment transactions today. But direct payments are not the only basic advantage for the merchant under PSD2. Through the right to view the customer’s account balance (with the customer’s permission), combined with collected data, merchants will be able to offer their loyal clients benefits such as smaller loans or payment in a larger number of installments. Looking at all of the above, if we were to use the terminology of social networks, the opportunities brought by the application of new technologies in the retail industry deserve one big “like”!


About the author

Goran Bosankić, Founder of PayconGoran Bosankić, ETA CPP, is the founder of Paycon, an independent payments and banking advisory. Fifteen-plus years across card acquiring, payment orchestration, EFTPOS, 3D Secure, core and digital banking and BaaS. Former CEO of ABC TECH Group and CRO of Field39. LinkedIn · [email protected] · More about Paycon


More from the archive on the Insights page, and a full list of bylined work on Publications. If this topic is on your agenda, get in touch.