A cashless society on the horizon

April 2016 · ATM & unattended retail · From the Ja Trgovac archive

First published in Croatian in Ja Trgovac, the Croatian retail trade magazine, April 2016 issue (pp. 50–52), as “Bezgotovinsko društvo na vidiku”. Republished here in English translation without changes. At the time, Goran was Pre-Sales Manager, BU Payment, at Asseco SEE. Figures, products and regulation are described as they stood in April 2016.

Croatia is closely following the global trend toward the ideal of an economy in which cash does not exist. So the next time you buy something from an online store or pay for your favorite snack at a vending machine with your contactless card, be proud, because you are making your contribution to the future.

As in all other aspects of life, spring marks a time of awakening in the card industry too, so there is plenty of news. From new possibilities in online retail and legal regulations to the appearance of card payments in branches of commerce where they have so far been poorly represented, everything tells us that the market is more active than ever before.

Cart abandonment

Phone cases, USB sticks and colorful “gadgets” pile up in our drawers simply because buying them is so easy. We click on the product, choose payment, log in to a well-known online payment service and voilà! A few days later a brand-new colorful trinket arrives from China. But have you ever wondered how many such trinkets would be gathering dust in our drawers if the payment process were far more complicated? Research regularly conducted on this topic gives an unambiguous answer: very few.

According to the latest data from one of the most prominent global portals specializing in the payments industry, pymnts.com, abandonment of the cart at the final step of an online purchase, so-called “check-out abandonment”, is almost unanimously considered the biggest problem of online retail today. In short, according to that portal’s research, as many as 40% of all purchases are lost at precisely this step. Expressed in real currency, the projected value of “carts” abandoned at the final step of purchase globally for 2016 reaches a staggering 158 billion US dollars! In other words, many times the budget of the Republic of Croatia (and of many other countries) ends up as revenue somewhere else, and not on the online merchant’s balance sheet.

There are several reasons for this, but the primary one lies in the simplicity of the final checkout process, i.e. completing the transaction. Whether customers give up because of unexpected costs such as delivery, an unsupported payment method, an awkward end to product or cart selection (the “check-out” process) or, most commonly, a complicated payment process, a large part of the figure above would still end up as the merchant’s revenue if only the customer had a somewhat simpler last step in the purchase process.

That is exactly why online merchants focus on making checkout as simple as possible, and the vast majority find the answer in a solution that allows card data to be stored in a secure environment by certified providers of such a service. In this way, besides the advantage of a simplified payment process, the merchant also eliminates the cost of the security certifications it would face if it stored card data in its own environment. The stored data is then used for every transaction without the user having to re-enter all the card details; instead, the purchase is completed quickly and simply with a single click and possibly the entry of a security code (the so-called “CVC”). This way of paying online, whether it is called “one-click payment”, “FastPayment” or something else, was first introduced by the biggest players in the world of online retail, such as Amazon.

New regulation

Since the Croatian market follows trends in this segment quite well, during this year this simple payment functionality will also be offered here by certain banks that provide e-commerce services to merchants. With such a service the merchant gains multiple benefits: sales volume increases and the customer return rate rises sharply, because the process is much simpler for the customer when the card data is stored and payment is made with a single click. At the same time, of course, regardless of the desire for simplicity, payment security must never be compromised. This method of payment is therefore carried out only with cards stored in the most secure way possible, in the secure environment of a certified provider of this service mentioned above, with the user authenticated using the well-known authentication method for card payments, so-called 3D Secure. During the first transaction, or when storing the card in the virtual vault (or the popular “wallet”), the customer enters an additional code besides the standard card data. This code is usually generated by the token the customer otherwise uses for internet banking, or delivered by SMS. In recent years this method of additional authentication has become established as the standard for secure online shopping.

As such it has been encouraged and supported by the card companies, and through upcoming EU regulation of card payments it will in the coming years also become a mandatory way of protecting participants in online commerce across the entire EU. That regulation, based on the famous PSD2 (Payment Service Directive), a set of guidelines from an expert body of the European Commission that are binding on EU national legislation, was adopted with the intention of regulating various areas of financial business, especially payments. The basic premise behind the directive is to enable innovation in the payments world, encourage healthy competition and ultimately raise the level of security for the end customer.

Merchants already had the chance to feel certain effects of this regulation at the end of last year, through its impact on card payment fees (so-called MIF) and the transparency of how these are presented by payment acquirers (banks and card companies). In the context of online retail, the directive’s impact on merchants goes further, in the form of the aforementioned obligation of strong authentication of the payment cardholder, so-called SCA (Strong Customer Authentication).

Identity is key

In every card transaction in the online world, the key security problem is proving that the person in front of the screen is also the owner of the card whose data is being used for payment. For all participants in the chain, the customer/cardholder, the merchant and the bank, to be sure that no criminal act is taking place, the cardholder’s identity must be proven. This is done precisely by the mechanisms described above, which combine several levels of security checks. For authentication to comply with SCA security standards, at least two of three elements must be satisfied: something the user has (e.g. a code generated by a token), something the user knows (the PIN entered on the token to generate the security code), and something the user is (e.g. a fingerprint). This achieves the highest level of security for the cardholder, for the merchant and ultimately for the bank. In the end, the combination of this kind of security check and the simplicity of paying with stored cards makes a winning combination and an ideal compromise. Indeed, it is a compromise that will significantly reduce the revenue lost through abandoned online purchases. And online retail in our country is growing constantly. According to the latest available data, more than 3.5 billion kuna of turnover was generated through the online sales channel last year alone. If we apply the global 40% of revenue lost through abandonment to that figure, we find that an impressive 2.3 billion kuna was lost on top of the 3.5 billion achieved. A figure that leaves no one indifferent. And the offer is bigger than ever. Proof of this is the recent entry of our largest physical retailer into a major new online retail project whose ultimate goal is to create a regional counterpart to the famous Amazon. And I believe that for them, as for the other players in this growing market, simplicity and security of payment will be the backbone of their business.

The self-service trend

The online world is not the only area of commerce in which card payments take place without the physical presence of the merchant. Today’s pace of life demands the availability of goods and services 24 hours a day in the physical world too, so the offer through various self-service devices is growing strongly. Whether simple drink and food vending machines, advanced parcel drop-off and delivery services or transport ticket sales, there is a dedicated device for everything. Although until recently the rule for such services was “cash is king”, the situation is slowly changing here too. It is impossible to ignore the fact that the average Croatian citizen has more than two payment cards, mobile payments are expanding and contactless cards are the standard. So losing a sale because a payment method is not supported, in this case cards, is a luxury few merchants can afford today. This is where so-called “unattended”, i.e. self-service payment POS terminals come in, a special category of devices adapted for use in self-service environments. Paying by card on such a device is as simple and secure as on a standard payment terminal in a store, with one difference: the customer does everything alone. This is where the simplicity of the payment process comes to the fore, because in our market the usual procedure is for the customer to hand their card to the merchant, the merchant performs the necessary technical steps and the customer only enters a PIN or signs a receipt. With self-service devices, the “merchant” is the device itself, and it is important to guide the customer correctly through the whole procedure so that the purchase is simple and at the same time gives a sense of security and trust. From the perspective of card payment potential, an important fact is the impressive number of such self-service devices in our market: more than 27,000. Given that an almost negligible number of them are equipped with payment terminals, it is clear that this segment is set for exceptional growth in the coming period. Customers are ready, banks are ready, suppliers of traditional cash acceptance mechanisms are slowly turning to suppliers of payment terminals, and the card companies are watching the situation closely and view this trend in our market very positively.

Telemetry data

Introducing card payment terminals into the self-service segment also brings an extremely important advantage that is not directly related to payments. Each of these payment terminals requires internet access to communicate with the card authorization server (the bank). Internet access, or any other form of communication, has not been common practice on self-service devices until now. However, since our coffee, juice, snack and ticket machines and the like are now inevitably getting a connection to the online world, merchants can benefit greatly from this. Whether through GPRS communication on the terminal itself or by installing a fixed network line for the payment terminal, merchants gain the ability to collect valuable data from self-service devices, so-called telemetry. It is now possible to have a precise, real-time view of the stock on each individual device, the turnover achieved, the condition of the device itself and a host of other data that most devices already record today but which is mostly collected manually at long intervals. The fact that all this data becomes available in real time has multiple benefits for merchants. Device downtime due to faults or lack of stock is drastically reduced because the information is available immediately, which delivers the two most important benefits for the merchant: savings and increased revenue. How? Savings come from a highly optimized operating process, in which the self-service network is serviced in a targeted way with minimal “idle running”. Increased revenue, in turn, comes not only from accepting card payments but also from the fact that device downtime, and therefore time lost for sales, is reduced to a minimum, i.e. to the time needed for an on-site intervention. Taking all of the above into account, from the merchant’s perspective introducing a payment terminal brings both savings and increased revenue at the same time. An opportunity that very rarely comes along today.

The near future

Although it often seems that card payments are present everywhere, there is clearly still plenty of room for progress. Security and simplicity are the key concepts on which the future of card payments is being built, and all segments of the industry strive to achieve the highest degree of both, with as few compromises as possible, all for the benefit of the end user: the customer. Some Scandinavian countries are very close to the stated goal of a “cash-free” society, i.e. an economy in which cash does not exist. It is true that we are very far from that, and perhaps we will never completely eliminate paper money, but it is an indisputable fact that we are following developments and are hardly lagging behind global trends at all. So the next time you buy something from an online store or pay for your favorite snack at a vending machine with your contactless card, be proud, because you are making your contribution to the future.


About the author

Goran Bosankić, Founder of PayconGoran Bosankić, ETA CPP, is the founder of Paycon, an independent payments and banking advisory. Fifteen-plus years across card acquiring, payment orchestration, EFTPOS, 3D Secure, core and digital banking and BaaS. Former CEO of ABC TECH Group and CRO of Field39. LinkedIn · [email protected] · More about Paycon


More from the archive on the Insights page, and a full list of bylined work on Publications. If this topic is on your agenda, get in touch.